Welcome to Negative World hero

Book Review: Welcome to Negative World, edited by Joe Rigney

Reviewed By

Joe Rigney (ed.). Welcome to Negative World: How to Read the Times You’re In. Moscow, ID: Canon Press, 2026. 172 pp.

In 2022, Christian writer and podcaster Aaron Renn published an essay titled “The Three Worlds of Evangelicalism” for First Things magazine. In it, Renn laid out a taxonomy of Christianity’s decline in American life since the 1950s. He frames the “Positive World” as lasting from the 1960s until about 1994; during this period, Christian morality largely retained cultural authority and prestige. In the “Neutral World” (1994-2014), Christianity lost its cultural authority, but being a Christian was culturally acceptable as one valid lifestyle choice among many. However, in the “Negative World” (2014-present), historic Christian teaching is seen as at odds with an emerging public morality promoted by many sectors of elite society, and those who try to hold to that teaching often face professional or even legal consequences.

Sponsored

The article went viral, prompting Renn to publish a book, Life in the Negative World, with Zondervan in 2024. Both the article and book have been widely discussed in Christian media, and the “Three Worlds” framework has become a common reference point in the discussions about the church and society. Renn was even the subject of a respectful New York Times profile in March 2025, and a prominent consulting firm recently named him as the most important “super-influencer” on the so-called “New Right.”

Given this context, it is not surprising that Canon Press has published a volume of essays engaging with Renn’s framework. Welcome to Negative World: How to Read the Times You’re In contains seven responses to Renn by evangelical pastors and public figures, followed by a concluding response from Renn. Taken as a whole, the volume provides a helpful orientation to how theologically conservative evangelicals are currently wrestling with the Three Worlds framework.

Have We Always Been in Negative World?

Douglas Wilson’s introduction acknowledges the complexities of Renn’s attempt to paint the recent history of American evangelicalism’s decline with a broad brush. Several commentators have tried to dismiss the Three Worlds framework by appealing to truisms about the prevalence of sin, worldliness, and opposition to the Gospel in every period of history, essentially claiming that “it has always been Negative World.”

In response, Wilson accurately points out that “a pietistic concern over universal worldliness is not really a concern about the demographic, sociological, and political realities of a particular cultural moment. We are not actually addressing the same concern.” (I made a similar point in my own 2024 review of Renn’s book, perhaps less charitably than Wilson does here.) In conclusion, Wilson notes that the way forward is not entirely clear; mainstream culture may become increasingly hostile to historic Christianity, or we could be approaching a significant revival. The church must plan for both eventualities.

The Three Worlds and the Tao

As is typical in edited volumes like this one, the other six essays responding to Renn’s thesis vary in length and quality. Rather than summarize each, I will focus on the two I found most provocative. The first of these is Joe Rigney’s “The Three Worlds and the Tao,” which connects Renn’s thesis to C.S. Lewis’s discussion of natural law (“the Tao”) in The Abolition of Man. In Life in the Negative World, Renn briefly notes mainstream society’s rejection of natural law as a characteristic feature of the Negative World. Rigney goes further, claiming that “the Three Worlds framework is fundamentally about what C.S. Lewis called the Tao.” In other words, according to Rigney, it is mainstream American culture’s gradual rejection of the objective created order and embrace of the “poison of subjectivism” that explains Christianity’s deteriorating position in society.

Historically, many Americans might have rejected Christianity’s “peculiar doctrines,” such as the Incarnation or the Atonement, but they largely agreed with Christians on the need to ground the social order in the Tao. The abandoning of the Tao is what leads non-Christians to view Christians as hateful or bigoted as opposed to merely odd or quaint.

Rigney calls on the church to conserve the vestiges of the Tao that broader society still recognizes and to recover elements lost in culture and law. He outlines “three uses of the Tao”: as a mirror that reflects God’s goodness and exposes our own faults, as a tool to restrain evil, and as a guide for Christians to “value things according to their [objective] value.” In his response to the volume’s contributors, Renn calls Joe Rigney’s essay “very compelling” and thanks Rigney for providing a vocabulary that effectively describes the cultural rejection of Christianity’s moral and ethical framework.

Christianity and Cultural Influence

The other essay I will focus on is Steven Peter’s “In the Era of the Judges.” Peter alleges that both critics and supporters of Renn’s Three Worlds framework have often misunderstood it. This misunderstanding, he writes, stems from a prior misconception of how cultural influence actually works: “Evangelicals believe that cultural influence is a linear function of population. More Christians means more cultural influence.” In reality, a relatively small elite dominates cultural influence and disseminates it through its influential networks. That elite is now often overtly hostile to orthodox Christianity, increasing the risks of adherence to the faith. One mitigating factor in the Negative World is that cultural influence is less centralized than in the past, as expressive individualism erodes all kinds of public norms.

The combination of pervasive risk and a decentralized environment, writes Peter, means that, rather than being in Babylon, 21st-century American Christians are “in the era of the Judges.” He argues that this period in Israelite history, recorded in the Old Testament book of Judges, parallels our current moment. It was a time when “everyone did what was right in his own eyes” (Judg. 17:6), and both the people and their leaders increasingly discarded the laws and norms Moses had handed down. This period was also marked by weak or absent leadership. In his response to the contributors, Renn writes that Peter’s essay “probably states my Three Worlds thesis better than I do myself” and calls the contrast between Babylon and the era of the Judges “an important contribution to understanding our contemporary cultural landscape.”

A Counter Catechesis

In Life in the Negative World, Renn recommends that the church seek to become more resilient while also pursuing excellence. Peter notes a tension between these two strategies. A wholehearted pursuit of resilience, in which the church seeks to insulate its members from the risks of the Negative World, could further reduce its influence in the broader culture. On the other hand, a total focus on excellence might lead Christians to win places among the cultural elites while privatizing their faith in the process. Peter recommends a two-pronged strategy in which local churches “counter-catechize” their members against moral relativism while also taking on more responsibility for serving their communities’ needs. At the same time, he calls on the broader Protestant church to follow the late Tim Keller’s admonition to develop and implement Protestant Social Teaching by cultivating scholarly and professional networks.

Although I devote the most space to Rigney’s and Peter’s contributions, the other essays in Welcome to Negative World are certainly worth reading. They offer perspectives from ministers, educators, and legal experts, each applying the Three Worlds framework in different ways. Collectively, they offer a broad-spectrum approach that accepts Renn’s framework and seeks to formulate concrete, coherent strategies and tactics for the church to employ in response. The book is not as groundbreaking as Renn’s Life in the Negative World, but it extends its analysis in a useful way. Christians who found Renn’s book valuable will also find helpful ideas in this volume to implement in local churches and society more broadly.


Disclaimer

A book review on Anglican Compass does not constitute an endorsement of the views, writings, and public statements of the book’s authors, contributors, editors, or publishers. Likewise, the review author’s views are solely their own and do not represent those of Anglican Compass, its authors, editors, or ministry board.


Image: Welcome to Negative World, © 2026 Canon Press.

Published on

October 29, 2026

Author

Jason Jewell

Jason Jewell is Chief Academic Officer and Vice Chancellor for Strategic Initiatives of the State University System of Florida. He worships at St. Peter’s Anglican Cathedral in Tallahassee, Florida.

View more from Jason Jewell

Comments

Please comment with both clarity and charity!

Subscribe to Comments
Notify of
0 Comments