King of Glorie, King of Peace: A Reading of George Herbert’s “Praise (II)”
Before he died, the Anglican priest and poet George Herbert sent a collection of poems to his friend Nicholas Ferrar, asking him to publish it or burn it. Ferrar chose not to burn it, thank God! Instead, he brought out the first edition of The Temple to the public that same year, 1633, and it has remained in print ever since.
“King of Glorie, King of Peace,” originally simply titled “Praise (II)” is one of the best poems in The Temple, but it is not one of the most famous. We usually know it today through the hymn of the same name, two versions of which I highlight at the end of this article. But comparatively little attention has been given to the poem’s actual meaning.
Below, I’ll offer a close reading of the poem as a dialogue of human prayer and divine response, and of man’s praise for God’s forgiveness. I also explore how this poem captures the drama between God and man. As we proceed, we will see this poem reflects Herbert’s own description of The Temple, as “a picture of the many spiritual Conflicts that have passed betwixt God and my soul, before I could subject mine to the will of Jesus my master.”
Stanza by Stanza
The poem has seven stanzas, but the first six are organized in pairs, with an initial stanza emphasizing man’s prayer and confession, and the next representing God’s response and forgiveness. Note the first-person pronoun “I” in the first stanza and the second-person pronoun “Thou” in the next. Here, we will look at these paired stanzas together and finally consider the concluding seventh stanza.
Stanzas 1 & 2
King of Glorie, King of Peace,
I will love thee:
And that love will never cease,
I will move thee.Thou hast granted my request
Thou hast heard me:
Thou didst note my moving breast,
Thou hast spar’d me.
“King of Glory” is a Biblical phrase that appears repeatedly in Psalm 24, referring to God as a mighty warrior returning to the city gates after great triumph.
Who is this King of glory?
Psalm 24:8
The LORD, strong and mighty,
the LORD, mighty in battle!
The King’s return is very exciting! But it is also a problem for us because we are sinners. The King returns in holy triumph, and we know that we are not holy. As Psalm 24 tells us, and as we know ourselves, only “he who has clean hands and a pure heart” may ascend with the holy one and stand in his place.
Thus, in addition to the “King of Glorie,” we also need a “King of Peace,” one who can not only rout the enemy, but also bring healing and holiness to his own people. This is the meaning of the last line in the first stanza, where the poet prays to move God from his righteous judgment to his gracious mercy.
The second stanza records God’s active forgiveness. Note the fourfold repetition of “Thou.” While the poem begins with man’s prayer, God’s response emphasizes his fourfold action: God grants, hears, notes, and spares. In other words, God is true to his word, paying attention to his people’s prayer and forgiving them by his grace.
Stanza 3 & 4
Wherefore with my utmost art
I will sing thee,
And the cream of all my heart
I will bring thee.Though my sinnes against me cried,
Thou didst clear me;
And alone when they replied
Thou didst hear me.
In light of God’s forgiveness, the third stanza sets forth the praise and devotion that we return to God. It comes in the form of song and gifts, offered “with my utmost art” and “the cream of all my heart.” Just as cream is the most valuable and delicious part of a pail of milk, so we bring God the best product of our hearts: our best love, our best joy, our best peace.
The fourth stanza dramatizes how God’s forgiveness continues, even when our sins accuse us. A modern praise song captures the same idea, though less elegantly, when it writes, “Our sins they are many, his mercy is more.” Notice again, however, that God’s mercy is depicted in the second person: “Thou didst clear me… Thou didst hear me.”
Stanza 5 & 6
Sev’n whole days, not one in seven,
I will praise thee.
In my heart, though not in heav’n
I can raise thee.Thou grew soft and moist with tears,
Thou relentedst:
And when Justice call’d for fears,
Thou disentedst.
The fifth stanza begins with one of my favorite lines in Christian poetry: “Seven whole days, not one in seven / I will praise thee.” In his introduction to George Herbert, Stephen Noll describes how Herbert embraced the life of prayer throughout the week. Though Sunday is a day for public worship and devotion, our praise continues in different keys through the round of our seven days. We praise God in our private prayers, in the love and care we give our neighbor, in the workplace labor of production and the family labor of reproduction. We do all these things as unto the Lord, giving praise and glory to the King of Glory.
The sixth stanza is often omitted from musical settings of this poem, but it matters to the poem’s meaning because it adds two images to its account of God’s forgiveness. First, it uses the language of personal pity, God’s softness and tears showing his care for us. Second, it uses the language of legal pardon, God refraining from inflicting the full force of the law.
Stanza 7
Small it is, in this poor sort
To enroll thee:
Ev’n eternitie is too short
To extoll thee.
Where the first six stanzas alternated between an “I” stanza and a “Thou” stanza, the last stanza combines the two into a “Thee” stanza.
Deeply assured of God’s forgiveness, the poet can now rest in God. Even though the poet is only “a poor sort,” he will now “enroll thee.” And we know that this praise is for him a great joy, since “ev’n eternity is too short / To extoll thee.”
In L’Envoy
Herbert notably uses the same opening line in another poem: “L’Envoy.” L’Envoy is the final entry in The Temple, and its first four lines are as follows:
King of glorie, King of peace,
With the one make warre to cease;
With the other blesse thy sheep,
Thee to love, in thee to sleep.
This confirms how Herbert sees “King of Glory” and “King of Peace” as two distinct but equally necessary roles. We need God to triumph outside us against our enemies, but we also need him to heal us inside from our sin. Praise be to God for doing both in his Son Jesus Christ!
As a Hymn
Herbert’s poem has been set to music in multiple settings that variously reflect Christ’s kingly glory and his kingly peace.
Most settings, however, do the hymn an injustice by omitting stanza 6. This enables the settings to use three double verses, but at the cost of losing the third “IโTHOU” pairing in Herbert’s poem.
I propose an alternative approach: retain the sixth stanza in the hymn, then repeat the second half of the tune to sing the seventh and final stanza. This would suit the poetry by giving the final, distinctive stanza a unique musical treatment.
On Video
In England, the customary tune is the majestic GWALCHMAI, sung in the first video at Westminster, with organ and brass, on the occasion of Queen Elizabeth II’s 90th birthday. This setting reflects the “King of Glory.”
In America, you will also hear the contemplative GENERAL SEMINARY, sung in the second video by the choir of All Saints Beverly Hills. This setting reflects the “King of Peace.”
Image: Photo by Paul Zoetemeijer on Unsplash. Digitally edited by Jacob Davis.
