M.R. James and the Anglican Ghost Story
A traveler takes lodgings in a remote, age-old inn. A visitor journeys to a mysterious, stately, centuries-old country manor. A new clergyman settles into his duties in an ornate Gothic cathedral. A scholar discovers a mysterious artifact in ancient ruins. Scenes like these stir the imagination and create the perfect premise for a ghost story. They rehearse a classic scenario: a modern person encounters something ancient and storied, evoking something beyond human understanding. Such meetings belong to ghost stories, but they also resonate with the Anglican life. Through our liturgy and our very theology, we constantly bridge the tangible and intangible, the current and the ancient.
Perhaps it is no surprise, then, that the most influential author of the classic English ghost story was a Cambridge-based scholar of antiquitiesโand the devout son of an Anglican priest. M.R. James was, you might say, born to write these stories. His tales are distinctive for both their subtle, creeping dread and the unmistakable moral and spiritual undercurrent that runs through them. Beneath his antiquarian horrors lies a worldview shaped by reverence for the sacred, a strong awareness of sin, and a fascination with mystery.
Who Was M.R. James?
An Anglican Upbringing
Born in 1862, Montague Rhodes James grew up in the rectory at Great Livermere in Suffolk, where his evangelical Anglican father, the Rev. Herbert James, served as vicar. As a clergymanโs son, he grew up immersed in the Anglican rhythms of Scripture and the liturgies of the Book of Common Prayer. His education at Eton and Kingโs College, Cambridge, carried him into institutions equally steeped in Anglican life. Although James never took holy orders like his father, he remained a dedicated Anglican for life. Later in life, serving as Provost of Kingโs College and then Eton, he continued to live within the familiar rhythm of chapel services.
Antiquarian Interests Set the Stage
As a scholar, James immersed himself in Christian antiquity, especially its more odd, obscure elementsโthe stranger, the better. His academic work on New Testament apocryphal writings, medieval manuscripts, and ecclesiastical art shaped both his intellect and his imagination. His interest in apocryphal writings did not lead him to treat them as equivalent to the canonical New Testament. In the preface to The New Testament Apocrypha, he defended that distinction while acknowledging the writingsโ historical and literary interest.
It will very quickly be seen that there is no question of any oneโs having excluded them from the New Testament: they have done that for themselves.
James, The New Testament Apocrypha, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1924, Preface.
Meanwhile, the daily surroundings of Jamesโs professionโlibraries, cloisters, and cathedralsโbecame the natural settings for his fiction. In his collections, beginning with Ghost Stories of an Antiquary, James sent his characters into rooms and passages much like those he knew, then allowed something unfamiliar to intrude. In these settings, the sacred and the scholarly meet, and the otherworldly stirs.
The Character of an Anglican Ghost Story
Jamesโs ghost stories feature many of the genreโs foreboding tropes inherited from his Victorian-era forebears, such as old buildings; an unsuspecting, irreverent protagonist; and a pervasive sense of dread.
The prose that sustains this dread almost mirrors Anglican liturgy: measured, literate, highly intentional, and elegantly understated. He avoids sensationalism, preferring suggestion to spectacle. His horrors unfold with the slow inevitability of a chant. This restraint deepens the terror, as the reader begins to sense vast, unspoken realities. In his introduction to Ghosts and Marvels, edited by V. H. Collins, James writes,
[T]wo ingredients most valuable in the concocting of a ghost story are, to me, the atmosphere and the nicely-managed crescendo.
M.R.James in Ghosts and Marvels, edited by V. H. Collins (Oxford University Press, 1924)
Just as James’ style reveals the influences of Anglican liturgy, his stories reveal a theological underpinning. Jamesโ ghost stories often read as moral dramas cloaked in antiquarian mystery. They concern not random hauntings but transgressionsโsomeone uncovers, removes, or summons what might have been better left undisturbed. The horror that follows is less chaotic terror than a consequence of moral trespass.
The Haunting of Sacred Places
Anglican theology has long affirmed that the material world can be sacramental, that visible things may convey spiritual realities. In Jamesโ fiction, an old whistle, a scrap of parchment, or a carved figure may bring something unseen uncomfortably close. The resemblance is suggestive, not exact: these objects are not sacraments, nor should we see his creatures as straightforward illustrations of Christian teaching, but they unsettle our assumption that what we can see is all there is.
In โThe Stalls of Barchester Cathedral,โ that unease settles into the church itself. Supernatural forces associated with the cathedralโs ornate choir carvings ultimately destroy Archdeacon John Benwell Haynes, D.D., a clergyman who has murdered his predecessor on church grounds. What first appears to be familiar church furniture grows less reassuring. The cathedral is no mere backdrop: its wood and stone keep a history that outlasts those who worship there.
Haynesโs wrongdoing gives this haunting moral weightiness. It becomes a tale of violated holiness, even if its workings do not fit neatly into Anglican doctrine. Here, Barchester Cathedral is a place where the past refuses to withdraw and where a personโs actions reach beyond what he can see. This sense of time gathered in one place resonates with Anglican worship: the centuries-old liturgy and sacraments draw us into a fellowship that includes Christians long departed and now in glory. In the Church, we are surrounded by a great cloud of witnesses (Heb. 12:1) and never truly alone.
The Past Comes Alive
The past presses close elsewhere in Jamesโs stories, too. Drawing on his antiquarian interests, he often begins in a recognizable world before reaching back into something much older. In his introduction to Ghosts and Marvels (1924), he recommends just enough distance to soften our familiar outlines:
โFor the ghost story, a slight haze of distance is desirable. โThirty years ago,โ โNot long before the war,โ are very proper openings.
M.R. James in Ghosts and Marvels, edited by V.H. Collins, pp. 407โ408
Even within that slight haze, James’ protagonists face echoes of something far more ancient. In โCanon Albericโs Scrap-Book,โ a scholar purchases a late-seventeenth-century scrapbook containing even older manuscript leaves. These are linked to a canon tied to the bookโs dark history; its contents bring the scholar within reach of a demonic presence. James spent his working life studying manuscripts just like these. His scholarship asked what they could reveal about the past. His fiction asks what else might come with them.
Here, too, an Anglican dimension emerges. The Church of Englandโs relationship with its own medieval inheritance is complicated. The Reformation changed its theology and worship, but it didn’t erase its churches, manuscripts, or even many of its traditionsโthings present in James’ everyday life. James returns to that older, medieval Christian world again and again in his stories, and he finds it is not always something we can examine from a safe distance.
The Unseen World and Its Dangers
Sometimes the smallest discovery opens the widest door. In โOh, Whistle, and Iโll Come to You, My Lad,โ a Cambridge professor checks into a remote seaside inn. On an excursion to a Knights Templar preceptory at an archaeologist friend’s request, he finds an ancient bronze whistle in a hole in the masonry. After taking it back to his room at the inn and cleaning it, he blows the whistle. He soon finds that the two-bed room he has occupied alone now has a malevolent new occupant.
James rarely explains precisely what his supernatural beings are. Some resemble human ghosts, but most seem older, stranger, and less easily named. Traditional Christianity distinguishes among departed souls, angels, demons, and other spiritual beings. St. Paul reminds us that our fight is against “the rulers, against the authorities, against the cosmic powers over this present darkness, against the spiritual forces of evil in the heavenly places” (Eph. 6:12). The Christian tradition does not teach that every apparent ghost must be a human spirit. In fact, in Protestant (including most Anglican) beliefs, that is rarely, if ever, the case. However, James’ stories offer no tidy map of the unseen world. Their creatures remain unsettlingly beyond explanation.
The professor has made an invitation without knowing whom, or what, he has invited. His learning gives him no command over the visitor. The whistleโs danger lies in that gap between curiosity and understanding.
Curiosity, Pride, and Reverence
That gap recurs throughout Jamesโs fiction. His protagonists, often learned, highly curious men not unlike himself, can remind us of a failing far too familiar to Anglicans and many other Christians: knowledge without humility. Their trouble often begins not in wickedness but in the confidence that a mystery is theirs to solve, a hidden knowledge theirs to obtain, a sin as old as Eden.
In โA Warning to the Curious,โ the danger reaches into the English countryside. An amateur archaeologist uncovers an ancient crown that legend says protects the realm. A spectral guardian pursues him. He returns the crown, but the pursuit doesn’t end, and it ultimately leads to his demise. The lonely, windswept coast here feels haunted by more than a ghost: an age-old duty still holds its ground. Curiosity has become irreverence, and putting things right comes too late.
A Legacy of Faith in the Shadows
The quiet, tempered unease of James’ stories lives on in later writers such as Susan Hill, whose novel The Woman in Black, rooted in English soil and haunted by guilt and loss, feels at home alongside James’ stories. His stories have continually been republished in large collections such as The Collected Ghost Stories of M.R. James from Oxford World Classics. His stories also retain their place at Christmastime, the season when he first told many of them to friends and pupils. What began with readings to friends at Kingโs College and Eton continues through seasonal adaptations, especially the BBCโs brilliant series, A Ghost Story for Christmas. The familiar room, the winter evening, the story quietly told: the setting still suits him.
James’ stories do not offer us allegories or homilies in disguise, yet we may hear familiar notes of the Anglican tradition in them: restraint, reverence, transgression, and mystery. His stories draw faith and fear close together, reminding us how readily the ordinary can open onto something extraordinary. We know the unseen is not always holy, nor is terror itself a revelation. Still, read through this lens, these ghost stories need not lead us away from faith. They may even renew our sense of humility and wonder, and ignite a candle to guide us through the darkness back to the true Light.
Image: The Haunted House (or A Moated Yorkshire Home) by John Atkinson Grimshaw (1874). Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons. Digitally edited by Jacob Davis.
