Confession: A Rookie Anglican Guide to the Reconciliation of Penitents

When I first explored Anglicanism, I was surprised to come across the Reconciliation of Penitents in my Book of Common Prayer. I was shocked as I read through the rite: this was confession! But wait, isnโ€™t confession a โ€œCatholicโ€ thing? We can approach God without going through a priest! Itโ€™s one of the hallmarks of Reformation theology! And yet, there it is in our 2019 Prayer Book, with a substantial tradition of practice behind it. So, what is confession from an Anglican perspective, and how do we practice it?

What is the Reconciliation of Penitents?

The Reconciliation of Penitents, commonly called auricular confession (auricular roughly means ‘audible’), appears on pages 223-224 in the 2019 Book of Common Prayer as one of the pastoral healing rites. As in the ministries to the sick and dying, the priest stands in on behalf of Christ and the Church to appeal to God on behalf of the person and to communicate to the person on behalf of God. Thus, the priest fulfills Jesus’ commission in John 20:23: “If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them; if you withhold forgiveness from any, it is withheld.” In this way, the priest acts like an emissary, saying only what the kingโ€”Godโ€”says is true and binding and acting on his behalf. Like other healing ministries, reconciliation actively works against the curse and demonstrates how God repairs what is broken in us and our world.

Sponsored

Is Anglican Reconciliation like Catholic Confession?

In contrast to the Roman Catholic practice of confession, most Anglicans do not consider the rite a sacrament, although, because it confers a type of grace, many still consider it a โ€œsacramental act.โ€ Others consider it a “Sacrament of the Church,” rather than the two “Sacraments of Christ”: Baptism and Holy Communion. Unlike the latter, auricular confession is not required to be an obedient church member. Confessing privately to God is still the way most Anglicans will practice repentance. However, it is a discipline that can lead to significant healing and spiritual growth if practiced.

How Do Anglicans Practice Reconciliation?

The rite begins with the penitent petitioning the priest,

Bless me, for I have sinned.

The priest then asks about the penitentโ€™s sins. The penitent will then recite the confession part of the liturgy, beginning,

I confess to Almighty God, to his Church, and to you, that I have sinned by my own fault in thought, word, and deed, in things done and left undone…

Then the penitent names the sins they have committed, voices their remorse, and asks God and the Church for forgiveness and the priest for โ€œcounsel, direction, and absolution.โ€ At this point, the priest can offer counsel or suggest an act of penance. Acts of penance are not some way of punishing oneself for sin. Instead, they are disciplines to help one grow and resist sin in the future. Finally, the priest pronounces Godโ€™s forgiveness on the penitent, often making the sign of the cross or placing his hand on the penitentโ€™s head. He ends by saying,

The Lord has put away all your sins.

The priest then offers a prayer. As the time together ends, the priest then requests,

Go (or abide) in peace, and pray for me, a sinner.

This last line is significant because it recognizes and reminds penitents that the priest is a sinner like themselves.

Why Should We Practice Reconciliation?

An oft-quoted mantra regarding auricular confession is attributed to Richard Hooker: โ€œAll may, some should, none must.โ€ Obviously, since we have โ€œan advocate with the Father, Jesus Christ the righteousโ€ (1 John 2:1) and we have the Holy Spirit within us who โ€œintercedes for us with groanings too deep for wordsโ€ (Romans 8:26), we can come before God on our own. And yet, in the Anglican tradition, we have a long history of confessing our sins and receiving absolution. The corporate version of this is an essential part of every Eucharistic liturgy. However, personal confession offers two additional benefits:

  • It provides a personalized expression of both the sins surrendered to Jesus and the pardon delivered to the penitent.
  • It brings an element of individual spiritual guidance specific to the penitent’s struggles.

Just because we can confess our sins to God directly doesnโ€™t mean we shouldnโ€™t practice confession with a confessor. Quite the opposite is true. By practicing the Reconciliation of Penitents, we lay our sins before God, are assured of his forgiveness, and receive pastoral guidance for the future. It should enhance, not replace, our personal relationship with God.

What If Iโ€™m Nervous?

Itโ€™s easy to feel intimidated the first time you confess to a priest. After all, you are about to lay all your cards on the table about your failures. Itโ€™s as vulnerable as a person can be. However, two pieces of comfort are important to remember:

  1. First and foremost, you are confessing to God, not the priest, and God already knows everything youโ€™re about to tell him. No sin is kept in the dark from God. God welcomes you to acknowledge your sin in the light, place it on Christ, and accept his forgiveness.
  2. The priest hearing your confession is as much of a โ€œmiserable offenderโ€ (in the old Prayer Bookโ€™s words) as you are. He has also likely heard many other confessions, in addition to knowing the weaknesses of his own heart, so youโ€™re not likely to shock or disturb him.

A Quick Thing to Note

Before confessing, you should know that the conversation between the penitent and the priest is entirely confidential. This long-held sacred principle, theย Seal of the Confessional, must be upheld whenever possible. However, according to the guidance of many dioceses, an exception may occur when the life or well-being of the penitent or another person is in potential danger. This exception is becoming more prevalent as many states have attempted to pass laws that compel clergy to breach confessional privilege in these situations. Please check with your clergy about their practice on this issue.


Photo by Josh Applegate on Unsplash. Digitally edited by Jacob Davis.

Author

Jacob A. Davis

The Rev. Jacob A. Davis is Lead Editor of Anglican Compass. He is a priest in the Diocese of Christ Our Hope and lives in Louisville, Kentucky, where he serves as an Assisting Priest for Pastoral Care at Grace Anglican Church. Jacob holds a B.A. in English (2006) and an M.A. in Theology and Arts (2010). As a lifelong artist and storyteller, he loves to explore the intersection of Christian faith with art, creativity, and beauty.

View more from Jacob A. Davis

Comments

Please comment with both clarity and charity!

Subscribe to Comments
Notify of
9 Comments

Thank you for this helpful article. Does the ACNA offer any province-wide guidance on the Seal of the Confessional?

There doesn’t seem to be any province-wide guidance at the moment; however, at least a few dioceses do have some guidance in place, though I don’t know how widespread this is.

When I first came as a Roman Catholic visitor to the Episcopal church, where I am now a member, I was given an expression regarding confession: ” All may.– something something. –Some should.”
Can you provide the complete expression?

Yes, the expression is the one I referenced above from Richard Hooker, “All may, some should, none must,” although many people reverse the last two when reciting it. I originally heard it “…none must, some should.” I like the “some should” element, as it emphasizes the helpfulness of the practice. I might venture to say “most should.”

Can non-Anglican baptized Christians receive the rite of reconciliation in the Anglican church?

Yes, absolutely. While it isn’t common for a non-Anglican Christian to ask for the rite of reconciliation, it is perfectly welcome. I have heard the confession of a non-Anglican before.

Would a non-Anglican be able to receive absolution from the priest? I know the RCC will not give a non-Catholic absolution.

Hi, Jordan. Yes, a non-Anglican can receive absolution from an Anglican priest. Obviously, that person would need to 1) be a baptized Christian who is truly repentant of their sin and 2) believe that the priest actually has the authority to pronounce that absolution. That being so, I have heard a confession from someone who is not currently Anglican. Also, as a priest pronounces the general absolution at each Holy Communion or Daily Office service, and there are regular visitors from other traditions at those services, that absolution is also valid no matter what Christian tradition they are coming from, as long as they are truly repentant.

Last edited 1 year ago by Jacob Davis

Thanks! I am a PCA member with my wife and kids, but I’m definitely Anglican at heart, so I wanted to know if that’s something I could do is private confession and receive absolution. Hopefully someday I’ll be confirmed, but that’s all in God’s timing. Thank you!