Wearing the Collar

In my diocese, there are no policies, rubrics, or clear guidelines on when and where a priest must wear the clerical collar. A troika of local custom (what your fellow priests do), common sense (church services but not church picnics), and personal preference informs that choice. For a new priest, there is a trial-and-error feel to it. Show up at a gathering as the only priest with or without a collar. You wonโ€™t make that same mistake again.

Why Wear the Clerical Collar?

I wear the collar whenever and wherever a priest’s services or mere presence are reasonably required or desired. This includes all assemblies of the church for worship, prayer, study, and business. These events are important. Home visits, hospital calls, funerals, or weddings of family members or friends outside the diocese and in other churches also require it. After much prayer, discernment with my spiritual director, and reflection, I decided not to wear the collar when I teach each day in a public high school. Nor do I ask the director of schools for permission. It is a legal gray area. However, being in the South grants more leeway for public expression of faith than in other regions of the country.

Sponsored

My colleagues and administrators are aware that I am a priest. I often bring a clerical shirt to school to change into for an afternoon hospital visit. It is my students who concern me the most. I fear that the collar might distance me from the very ones who need a priest or simply a caring teacher the most. These are those on the margins, those with no real adult presence or guidance, and those who feel isolated and alone. For them, I can best be a priest incognito. My white shirt and tie are better suited for this than a black shirt and clerical collar. I also donโ€™t generally wear the collar when relaxing at home with my wife. However, in case of an emergency call-out, I always have a shirt pressed and ready.

However, all this still leaves large segments of my life unaccounted for. As I write this, I am sitting outside at a local cafรฉ on a Saturday morning, savoring a cup of coffee. Collar on? No, not todayโ€”not yet today. I havenโ€™t decided about later, after I mow and shower. Will I wear the collar to the mall this afternoon when I take my daughter to buy contacts? Or to the bookstore? What will inform my decision?

The Collar: A Connection to Other Churches

Earlier this year, I sat with my wife in the food court of an Orlando airport. My daughter and her male companionโ€”I still canโ€™t say boyfriend, though itโ€™s trueโ€”browsed the shops awaiting his flight departure. Some Orthodox clerics passed by across the concourse. They were very distinctive and noticeable with long beards and black cassocks. There my wife and I sat, 600 miles from home, anonymous, in the company of hundreds of total strangers. My heart leapt at the sight of these men. My people! These Orthodox priests would certainly consider me heterodox and perhaps even heretical.

Their presence reminded me that the Lord arose and is working in the world, not least through his Spirit-filled people. Their presence was a silent proclamation of the Gospel. I am certain there were many other faithful disciples of Christ in the Orlando airport that evening. However, they were anonymous and unknown. The cassock made the difference. In my shorts and sandalsโ€”I was on vacation, after allโ€”I made no oneโ€™s heart leap with joy for the risen Lord. This will inform my decision about wearing the collar to the mall or the bookstore.

The Collar: A Road to Evangelistic Opportunity

Yesterday afternoonโ€”thanks be to God it was Friday!โ€”my wife and I were relaxing for a few minutes at Barnes & Noble. We had just come from school, and I was still dressed in my โ€œteacher uniformโ€ of shirt and tie. I stood at the cafรฉ counter, awaiting our order, and enjoyed some friendly banter with the baristas. One of them said, โ€œDo you mind if I ask you a question? Iโ€™ve seen you in here with a collar on. Are you some kind of pastor?โ€ I explained to her that I was a surprised Anglican priest; she knew what an Anglican was. It seems her studies involve history and the history of religion, even though, as she acknowledged, she is not particularly religious.

We had an interesting, though brief, talk before my order came, and she left for the evening. (I had intended that discussion to be the topic of this post, but the writing went elsewhere, as it often does. I will return to it later.) But, I will see her again and frequently, and God only knows (truly) where this brief conversation might lead. It is all because of the collar. How many conversations have I missed by not wearing the collar in public, I wonder. The collar serves as an open and public invitation to strangers to strike up a conversation with me about important things. On several occasions, Iโ€™ve seen it do this. This will inform my decision about wearing the collar this afternoon.

When they had finished breakfast, Jesus said to Simon Peter, โ€œSimon, son of John, do you love me more than these?โ€ He said to him, โ€œYes, Lord; you know that I love you.โ€ He said to him, โ€œFeed my lambs.โ€ He said to him a second time, โ€œSimon, son of John, do you love me?โ€ He said to him, โ€œYes, Lord; you know that I love you.โ€ He said to him, โ€œTend my sheep.โ€ He said to him the third time, โ€œSimon, son of John, do you love me?โ€ Peter was grieved because he said to him the third time, โ€œDo you love me?โ€ and he said to him, โ€œLord, you know everything; you know that I love you.โ€ Jesus said to him, โ€œFeed my sheep.”

John 21:15-17

Understanding the Rationale Behind the Collar

When I was discerning the priesthoodโ€”and even before formal discernment had begun โ€”my spiritual director asked me wonderfully probing questions. โ€œWhy do you feel a need for ordination? What can you do with a collar that you canโ€™t do without one?โ€ The answers are many, and this is not the place to explore them. Nevertheless, I now realize, even if I didnโ€™t fully understand it then, that a priest’s unique calling is to be a public witness to the presence of Christ. This is not only in the parish, but in the world.

Using Discernment When Wearing or Refraining

In a nominally Christian culture that is, in reality, increasingly secular or pagan, the simple wearing of a collar is a countercultural act of Gospel proclamation. With no words necessary, the collar nonetheless testifies to the mystery of faith: Christ has died. Christ arose. Christ will come again. As a priest, I have this great opportunity. It is something I can do with the collar that I canโ€™t do as easily without it. This will inform my decision about wearing the collar this afternoon.

I also live in the South, and this is summer when the temperature and humidity both hover in the nineties. Who chose black for a clerical shirt? When the sun beats down and the sticky air makes it hard to breathe, a black clerical shirt and collar are miserable. Though Iโ€™m ashamed to say it, this uncomfortable physical reality will also inform my decision about wearing a collar this afternoon.

In my diocese, there are no policies, no rubrics, and no clear guidelines on when and where a priest is required to wear the clerical collar. It is a personal and private decisionโ€”certainly adiaphoraโ€”and I honor the various choices of my fellow priests. However, it is a decision I hope to make theologically and vocationally, rather than haphazardly or thoughtlessly. As trivial as it may sometimes seem, indeed, there are more important issues, arenโ€™t there? It is not unimportant.


Photo by: Marek Studzinski on Unsplash.

Author

John Roop

John Roop serves as Assisting Priest at Apostles Anglican Church in Knoxville, Tennessee, where he lives with wife of over 40 years, Clare. They have one daughter. He previously served many years in the Christian Church.

View more from John Roop

Comments

Please comment with both clarity and charity!

Subscribe to Comments
Notify of
12 Comments

What are your various priestly views about Permanent Deaconswearing the collar?

Ours typically do in my diocese.

Thank you, there is a debate raging loudly in my head. I will prayerfully consider dress when I leave the house. I have been told that in Georgia it is a turn off. But each time I am in public, outside of a church function, someone acknowledges or asks a question. Isn’t it about the one each day?

Paul, I have also heard that it could be a turn off, but perhaps that is because it is unfamiliar. I love it when my husband is stopped in public, especially when a stranger sits beside him to talk. The collar is a sign to them that they can talk to him about the things that deeply matter to them.

Great post on the collar, John. When I am in public without a collar, I often regret it. When I do wear it, it is not uncommon to be glad I did. Maybe we should not worry about what “they” say about it bothering people in someway in the South and trust the Lord to use it – as He seems to do, in unanticipated ways. Besides, people who are turned off by it need to have some lines drawn in their lives anyhow. The colour in the summer…. hm. Black is classic, for sure. How about light gray in the summer? That should help, I would think. Finally, one of my biggest problems is cost! It’s hard to afford to have enough of them to wear all the time. Thanks again!

Having been a full time clergyman for eight years, and part-time the last two, and also a teacher and professor for Catholic schools and institutions where I am not recognized as a priest formally, but have the respect of my students and colleagues, I resonate with your concerns about when is an appropriate time to make the switch. I certainly don’t wear my collar to run errands, mow the lawn, or to make dinner for my wife as we lounge at home. When I was full time, I lived in clericals because I was full time, and I never even considered changing to go to dinner, or before going to the store my way home.

However, I’ve noticed that posts like these don’t address those times when we gather as clergy, or even recent posts on Facebook by those who are among the top leadership of our church in particular, who frequently go to church in different parishes in the area without a collar, or who represent our church at our most important gatherings without a collar. Without presuming to proclaim why this is the case, I will speculate that there is an underlying discomfort and perhaps shame with the very idea of the collar. Would that they posited as deeply as this article, or had the brevity to wear it to church (of all places) and to have those thousands of little encounters such as you experienced at Barnes and Noble.

While some of my colleagues have far more snippy things to say about such clergy, I merely lament. I lament the loss of opportunities to change someone’s life when they come to you as a stranger and leave as a healed child of God, or at least closer to it than before. I lament the time they’ve had to read in a B&N without interruption to counsel someone who walks up to you because you’re the first clergy person they’ve ever met in public, and they really need some advice. Even my Roman Catholic colleagues are scarcely in clericals those days outside of the church, and there seems to be some stigma of what might happen.

In the (going on) ten years I’ve been in a collar, no one has ever come and attacked me, or asked a question I was unprepared to answer. No one who has asked, “Are you a priest/pastor/preacher?” Has ever followed with a negative comment. Rather I’ve heard more confessions in bars than in church, by a long shot. I’ve counseled people though things as simple as “What do you think of the new Pope?” to “I came home yesterday afternoon to discover my roommate had blown his head off with a shotgun.” While sitting at the airport last fall, I was asked to bless busload after busload of new soldiers coming through ATL to be sent off to a local army base, simply because I was there, waiting for a stranger at the airport.

I was present, and they asked. That is the formula.

This I lament on your behalf, because our Lord has ordained you to be his priest in this world, and when you remain anonymous,, their pain remains silent, their anxieties only grow, and you don’t gain this valuable experience in the hardest trenches in this battlefield: the public. This is your loss, and I lament it for you. I hope this influences your decision tomorrow afternoon.

I was ordained a Deacon in the Anglican Church in Tucson, AZ so the issue of the “black” shirt resonates with me. I do wear a light blue shirt from time to time. I remember writing in my examinations for ordination that I believed there were many things I could accomplish as a Deacon that were far more difficult as a layman – a major part of that was the “identity” tools available – shirt & collar – that made conversation easier to strike up. I still find it so and wear the collar frequently and everywhere!

I am a teacher and recently ordained deacon. I will be wearing my collar. In my school we have people wearing turbans, hijabs and other religious dress. My students will come to me regardless because they know I will advocate for them. It wonโ€™t distance me from them anymore than the fact that they know that Iโ€™m gay or it wonโ€™t distance them from me anymore than those who wear other types of the religious garments in my school. It becomes an opportunity for education and sharing.

As a deacon in a diocese that recently declared that deacons may no longer wear clerical attire, this conversation hits home.

In the short time I lived as an ordained man who wore the collar, I was delighted at all the times it was a silent witness and often opened the door for more vocal witness! I was asked for prayer and blessings. I had strangers on line in the grocery store say something rude, then turn and see me and say, “Sorry father, I know I shouldn’t say stuff like that.” And the practical benefit was obvious as someone who frequently visits nursing homes, funeral homes and cemeteries.

I think the new policy is terrible and I struggle to be obedient.

Be well.

(I realize this is an old post but perhaps people are still stumbling upon it as I did in 2024)

A troika of local custom (what your fellow priests do), common sense (church services but not church picnics, emphasis added)

I’m surprised this is “common sense”! I was at my charge’s (parish) picnic, and our Rector was wearing clericals (black shirt in formal style with a Roman collar, not a cassock), a visiting priest was wearing a blue formal shirt and Roman collar, and our assistant priest a jumper, shirt, and tab collar.

May a lay Canon, whose focus is evangelism, wear the collar to open opportunities for witnessing the Gospel?

Hi, Mike. Great question. The clerical collar is pretty much specifically for ordained clergy; other church leaders who are not clergy (vergers, vestry members, lay canons, etc.) do not even wear it. To do so would be confusing for church attenders and the general public. It would be like someone wearing a police uniform who was not a police officer. While the collar can occasionally present some opportunities for conversation, there are many other ways to engage others with the gospel.