Women Bishops and Reception: An Occasion for Rethinking

Editor’s Note: The Rev. Dr. Stephen Noll, now a board member of Anglican Compass, also served from 2015 to 2020 as the Convener of the GAFCON Task Force on Women in the Episcopate. In 2017, this Task Force issued a recommendation for a moratorium on the consecration of women bishops. In this article, we share Dr. Noll’s 2019 essay “Women Bishops and Reception,” together with a foreword from Dr. Noll.


The GAFCON Primates authorized the Task Force on Women in the Episcopate in 2015. The decision to focus on the episcopate was made for pragmatic and ecclesiological reasons: at that time, there were no women bishops in the GAFCON churches, and bishops in our polity are “heads” bearing authority within their dioceses and ecumenically. The Task Force included representatives—men and women, episcopal, presbyteral, diaconal, and lay, for and against women’s ordination—from eleven GAFCON provinces, representing a majority of the members of the Anglican Communion.

Sponsored

Task Force Recommendation

We met three times in person and submitted recommendations to the GAFCON Primates in 2017, the chief of which stated:

that the provinces of GAFCON should retain the historic practice of the consecration only of men as bishops until and unless a strong consensus to change emerges after prayer, consultation and continued study of Scripture among the GAFCON fellowship.

The Primates approved these recommendations. In 2019, the Task Force presented a 327-page Interim Report, with fourteen essays and a summary available here. My essay was titled “Women Bishops and Reception” [N.B.: “reception” is a term referring to how the Church “receives” the teaching of Scripture and passes it on (tradition)]. Once again, the Primates endorsed the Report and encouraged the Task Force to continue its work.

Women Bishops as a Secondary Issue?

The onset of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020 delayed further consultation. Before it could resume, the news broke in early 2021 of the election and consecration of a female bishop in the Anglican Church of Kenya. This event in one of the founding GAFCON provinces presented the Primates with a crisis similar to that faced by the Episcopal Church in the 1970s. When they met again (in-person and online) in September 2021, the Primates unilaterally changed their position, stating in their Communique:

The Jerusalem Declaration affirms that the Bible makes a distinction between salvation issues and other secondary issues. In our discussion, the Primates acknowledged that while there is disagreement and ongoing discussion on the issues of the ordination of women as deacons or priests, and the consecration of women as Bishops, we are agreed that these are not salvation issues and are not issues that will disrupt our mission: to proclaim Christ faithfully to the nations.

The Primates, it seems, are basing their decision on clause 2 of the 2008 Jerusalem Declaration, which states:

We believe the Holy Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments to be the Word of God written and to contain all things necessary for salvation.

Jerusalme Delcaration, Clause 2

So, they reason, if no explicit prohibition of women bishops exists in Scripture, the sex of a bishop is a secondary matter permitted according to clause 12, which reads:

We celebrate the God-given diversity among us which enriches our global fellowship, and we acknowledge freedom in secondary matters.

Jerusalem Declaration, Clause 12

As I understand them, the Primates are employing a minimalist reading of “salvation” and “mission” and a maximalist reading of secondary matters (adiaphora). 

But many elements of the biblical economy of salvation—the whole Gospel—go beyond the question: “What must I do to be saved?” (Acts 16:30). Proclamation (kerygma) is, to be sure, a crucial part of the mission of the church, but so is doctrine (catechesis) – “teaching them to observe all that I have commanded you” (Matt 28:19-20; Acts 1:2).

Similarly, while the Jerusalem Declaration affirms the sufficiency of Scripture, clause 2 goes on to say:

The Bible is to be translated, read, preached, taught and obeyed in its plain and canonical sense, respectful of the church’s historic and consensual reading.

Jerusalem Declaration, Clause 2

I have recently argued that this clause represents a “via media for orthodox Anglicans” based on classic Anglican formularies and texts such as Canon A5 of the Church of England (“Of the doctrine of the Church”), the Articles of Religion (VI and XIX), Cranmer’s Scripture Collect, and Richard Hooker’s maxim: 

what Scripture doth plainly deliver, to that the first place both of credit and obedience is due; the next whereunto is whatsoever any man can necessarily conclude by force of reason; after these the voice of the Church succeedeth.

Richard Hooker, Laws of Ecclesiastical Polity, V.8.2

The question which the GAFCON Primates dodged, as I see it, is whether ordination of a woman bishop is, in the words of Canon A5, contrary to the teaching of the church as “grounded in the Holy Scriptures, and in such teachings of the ancient Fathers and Councils of the Church as are agreeable to the said Scriptures.”

The Nomination of a Woman Archbishop

Of the many responses to the recent nomination of Dame Sarah Mullally to become Archbishop of Canterbury, most have either acclaimed it as a “historic first” on the road to equity or deplored it on grounds that her progressive views on abortion and same-sex marriage are contrary to the Bible and hence divisive among Anglicans at home and abroad.

Few have focused on the question of whether her female sex alone should disqualify her for the office. However, Archbishop Laurent Mbanda, chairman of the GAFCON Primates, did note in his statement that:

Though there are some who will welcome the decision to appoint Bishop Mullally as the first female Archbishop of Canterbury, the majority of the Anglican Communion still believes that the Bible requires a male-only episcopacy. Therefore, her appointment will make it impossible for the Archbishop of Canterbury to serve as a focus of unity within the Communion.

The Most Rev. Laurent Mbanda, “Canterbury Appointment Abandons Anglicans.” GAFCON, October 3, 2025.

As the former Convener of the GAFCON Task Force on Women in the Episcopate, I would like to argue that GAFCON’s objection to Dame Sarah represents not just nose-counting but also prior theological reflection on whether a woman’s ordination to the episcopate is consistent with Scripture and the received tradition of the Church and how the Church communally “rethinks” such a tradition. 

I am not here to cast stones but rather to ask whether the advent of a woman Archbishop of Canterbury, an office for many years considered a “focus of unity” in Anglicanism, should cause a rethinking among global Anglicans of our doctrine and discipline of Holy Orders. Rethinking may, in turn, require repenting of errors not only in the revisionist West but in our own movement.

To further this consideration, I am posting below an essay I wrote for the Task Force on Women in the Episcopate. For a published version of the essay, see my The Gospel of God and the Church of God: Global Anglican Essays (Anglican House Publishers, 2020).


 Image: Photo by JLGutierrez, courtesy of Canva. Digital editing by Peter Johnston.

Author

Stephen Noll

The Rev. Dr. Stephen Noll is Professor Emeritus at Trinity Anglican Seminary and retired Vice Chancellor of Uganda Christian University. He served on the Statement Group of the first three Global Anglican Future Conferences and gave an inaugural address at the fourth. He currently serves on the ministry board of Anglican Compass.

View more from Stephen Noll

Comments

Please comment with both clarity and charity!

Subscribe to Comments
Notify of
6 Comments

I found this to be a serious and well-argued reflection on the challenges posed by the ordination of women to the episcopate within contemporary Anglicanism. The author rightly points out that the issue demands more than pragmatic or conciliatory appeals: it calls for a genuine theological, ecclesiological, and liturgical reflection.

Allow me, however, to offer some objections from within the Tradition. This is not merely a personal opinion, but rather the recognition—attested by the Fathers and the unanimous ecclesial heritage—that the ordination of women to the priesthood and episcopate lacks sacramental validity, being an innovation foreign to apostolic theology and practice. To admit it is to introduce a grave rupture with the Tradition, a displacement of the normative principle received for centuries, not simply a disciplinary change.

In this sense, one might ask whether we are witnessing a kind of inverted papalism—a vision of unity that imposes doctrinal redefinitions in the name of modern consensus. Newman—before crossing the Tiber—remarked that the center of Anglicanism was “its bishop,” that is, local authority in communion. By altering the very sign of that authority, Anglicanism has fractured the symbolic axis of its identity.

The fruits are visible: internal division, doctrinal confusion, and a loss of continuity with the faith once held. It is not a development, but a refoundation under the sign of modernity.

With respect, yet with sadness,

Raúl, from Argentina

It amazes me that the GAFCON Anglican jurisdictions are either shocked or dismayed over this matter. What do you expect? So long as these(and other) jurisdictions continue to embrace female priests, this issue will continue to haunt them all. One cannot accept a little arsenic in your morning tea and not expect it to kill you eventually. Remove the plank from your own eye before trying to remove the splinter from another’s eye.

Women as priests and deacons is not the equivalent of “arsenic in your tea”. My parish has (and had) a number of female priests and deacons, including our rector’s wife, and a transitional female deacon who will be ordained as a priest in November. She is doing CPE at our local children’s hospital and they’re going to hire her after her ordination, although she’ll still help us out as time permits. She’s also a mom of three children, with the oldest being a college freshman, and the other two in high school.

Are we becoming the new Church of Rome where dogma is based on the opinion of men rather than than scripture?

No one doubts the sincerity of many ladies who feel called to ordained ministry nor that many are talented and bear much fruit but neither of these indicate that they should or even can be ordained. The first is subjective and the second reflects God’s grace . But the issue is one of sacramental certainty first and foremost and the need to stay within Tradition and the need to work for visible unity.

I would like to read the arguments that ACNA and GAFCON offer for accepting women into the diaconate and priesthood. Perhaps they have already addressed this topic, but I haven’t received much information. What I want to know is how they defend this position from the tradition of the Church.