Confirmation: A Rookie Anglican Guide

What is Confirmation?

Confirmation is a church practice that falls into the category of what the Anglican Catechism calls “rites and institutions commonly called sacraments.” Along with Confirmation, there are four others like it: Absolution (confessing one’s sins and receiving forgiveness in the presence of a priest), Ordination, Marriage, and Anointing the Sick.

These practices, or rites, are deeply charged “sites” of God’s grace. They are “commonly called sacraments” (and for some Anglicans, they are considered sacraments) because they are visible signs that confer an invisible grace. However, we distinguish them from the two primary sacraments of Baptism and Eucharist because those two are “commanded by Christ as necessary for salvation.”

Sponsored

While many Protestants shy away from calling Confirmation a sacrament in the strict sense, the Church’s witness throughout the ages, especially in the Anglican wing, has upheld it as a vital means through which God mediates grace to us.

Where Did Confirmation Originate?

Confirmation arose from the early Church’s reflection on Scripture concerning how one became a Christian. It first describes what happened when a bishop would lay hands upon, pray for, and anoint the forehead of the newly baptized with oil, signifying the gift of the Holy Spirit. The newly baptized/confirmed would then proceed to receive their first Eucharist.

Over time, Western churches gradually separated Confirmation from Baptism, unlike the Eastern Orthodox churches, which still promptly confirm infants after Baptism. In Anglican churches, the common practice involved infant baptism, followed by extensive instruction (catechesis) during adolescence, which prepared individuals for Confirmation. Once again, Confirmation was a prerequisite for receiving Communion. It’s also worth noting the distinctiveness of Confirmation; priests could perform baptisms, while Confirmation typically remained within the bishops’ domain.

Puzzling Over Confirmation Today

In recent history, the Church has ignored questions beyond Confirmation. A few concerns:

  • The Church connected Confirmation to Baptism very early. Does that mean that if you’re not confirmed, Baptism is insufficient?
  • The Church has often linked Confirmation to the Holy Spirit. Is the Spirit missing in Baptism?
  • What if there’s no bishop around to offer Confirmation (as there wasn’t in America for the first 200 years)?
  • Today, Confirmation is no longer required to receive Communion. If it’s not necessary for salvation and not needed for receiving Communion, why bother at all?

First, we would probably do well to begin with different questions. Maybe the question isn’t merely about salvationโ€”am I “in” or “out”? Why not ask: “What more does God have in store for us? What kind of life in Christ is God calling us to enter into more deeply?” If we ask these sorts of questions, we can better see what Confirmation is and why we should incorporate it more into the Church’s life.

Clarifying Confusion: Confirmation as Maturity and Mission

At its most basic, Confirmation is the rite in which, after a believer is baptized and makes a mature commitment to the faith, they receive an increased gift of the Holy Spirit through the bishop’s prayer, the laying on of hands, and anointing. Once again, the Catechism puts it beautifully. When asked, “What grace does God give you in confirmation?” the response is, “In confirmation, God strengthens the work of the Holy Spirit in me for his daily increase in my Christian life and ministry.” To clarify some of the confusion around Confirmation, I want to rework some of the questions about it and suggest that we think of Confirmation in terms of two key emphases: maturity and mission.

Growing Up: the Sacrament of Maturity

First, Confirmation is the sacrament of maturity, representing a deepening or strengthening of the Christian life, and connects closely with Baptism. Whereas Baptism highlights one’s birth into the body of Christ, Confirmation stresses growth. In both Baptism and Confirmation, the Holy Spirit is present; it’s a rule of Trinitarian theology that wherever there’s one person of the Trinity, all three are present. However, in Baptism, the Spirit washes away our sin, cleanses our guilt, and regenerates us into new life. In Confirmation, on the other hand, the Spirit deepens and strengthens that life so that we grow up into more mature Christians.

The great medieval theologian Peter Lombard nicely described the Spirit’s presence in Baptism and Confirmation:

The virtue โ€ฆ of the sacrament [of Confirmation] is the gift of the Holy Spirit for strength, who is given in baptism for remission.

Peter Lombard, The Sentences, Book IV, Distinction 7

In other words, the Holy Spirit’s forgiving gift in Baptism is only the beginning of a work of Confirmation that is fortifying and enriching.

Growing Out: the Sacrament of Mission

Second, Confirmation is the sacrament of mission. By this, I mean that Confirmation “marks” a person for undertaking the vocation Christ called us to do. In this regard, Confirmation is sort of like Ordination: it marks you out for a specific calling. But unlike Ordination, the Church confirms both lay people and priests. Why? It is because every Christian’s vocation is to proclaim the Gospel and live a holy life.

Hence, this is also why Confirmation links to the bishop’s presence. As Ordination into the priesthood requires the bishop’s presence, so too, in Confirmation, the bishop’s presence signifies that the confirmand receives the charge to carry on the apostolic mission. One area where thinking about Confirmation has gone wrong is to see it as a kind of graduation from Christian education and formation rather than a commencement. Too often, we think that once a person is confirmed, the journey ends; I was baptized, catechized, and confirmed. What else is there? Well, quite simply: everything! Far from being the end of the road, Confirmation marks a new beginning. It is a new, more profound sense of vocation. Confirmation marks you out for a life on mission.

Is Confirmation an Initiation, or is Baptism?

Some Anglicans have debated whether Baptism is a “complete sacramental initiation.” The logic is: if Baptism does the trick, why bother with Confirmation? What a slippery question. If someone means by this that Baptism is somehow insufficient for salvation, then no: Baptism is sufficient; Baptism makes Christians. Full stop!

Yet if by “initiation,” one means that we are always being initiated deeper into life with God, then yes, we can say that Baptism is “incomplete. All of life is incomplete until we see God face to face. Confirmation, then, is a sacramental practice uniquely related to the Holy Spirit’s ministry of maturity and strengtheningโ€”literally, with–firming, being made firm with (Latin, con-)โ€”the power of the Spirit. In this, we seek to live out what St. Paul writes in Ephesians about growing up into the full measure of Christ (Eph. 4:13).

Why Should I Pursue Confirmation?

If Confirmation is like an ordination for a life of Christian mission, where’s the mission field? Mission doesn’t just happen overseas. It happens everywhere: in our neighborhoods, homes, and the ordinary places of our everyday existence. Mission is right where we are, right now.

To reinvigorate and renew the practice of Confirmation is one of the most critical tasks for the Church today, because renewing Confirmation means renewing the Church’s mission. It means well-equipped, well-trained missionaries going out into the mission field of life, proclaiming the Gospel in all they do. It means further equipping all the saints for the work of God’s kingdom. And, finally, it means a rising generation of Christians who have dedicated their lives to the glory of God in every area of life.

And he gave the apostles, the prophets, the evangelists, the shepherds and teachers, to equip the saints for the work of ministry, for building up the body of Christ, until we all attain to the unity of the faith and of the knowledge of the Son of God, to mature manhood, to the measure of the stature of the fullness of Christ. . .

Ephesians 4:11-13

Photo by Caroline Hernandez on Unsplash 

Author

Alex Fogleman

Dr. Alex Fogleman is Associate Dean for Special Programs and Assistant Professor of Theology at Trinity Anglican Seminary.

View more from Alex Fogleman

Comments

Please comment with both clarity and charity!

Subscribe to Comments
Notify of
11 Comments

Excellent teaching. Wish we had an old order 1928BCP Anglican Mission here at Seneca Lake, East Ohio Redneck Hill Country, 100+ miles to: Columbus, Cleveland, Pittsburgh, Charleston, WV, Akron, Youngstown, in the middle of nowhere!!! We love it here!!!

Indeed really enjoyed the teaching so glad God send to me as we are about start our Confirmations Candidate Classes. What a privilege, I am going to make use of this valueable reseach. Thank you

Very informative article, but Anglicans who use the 1928 BCP and comply with its rubrics require confirmation of those desiring to receive communion.

If you have been confirmed in another denomination, why must you be re-confirmed in the Episcopal Church? In other words, if re-baptism is unnecessary, why is re-confirmation needed?

Great question. Anglicans recognize baptisms from other denominations that are done in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, not from particular ecclesial or episcopal affiliations. From early one, confirmation’s validity was tied to the laying on of hands by a bishop. Confirmation never got the same kind of theological controversy that baptize got, so the theology is a bit fuzzier. Nonetheless, as the theology of confirmation developed, it became tied to the bishop, and so the bishop’s relation to the succession of bishops that traces back to the first Apostles.

Confirmation, then, is a more direct link to the Apostolic ministry of proclaiming the gospel. This is why I stress in the post that it is the sacrament of mission.

But this is also why Anglicans “re-confirm” if the first “confirmation” was done in a non-episcopal church, that is, by churches that cannot articulate a line of apostolic succession. It’s also why a person who was confirmed in the Roman Catholic church is not confirmed but “received” into the Anglican communion, because in the RC tradition, confirmation is linked to the bishop’s role.

Hope that helps! Anytime we deal with the theology of a liturgical practice, it’s most always a “practice in search of a theology” (as in infant baptism especially), but such is the way it goes.

Thanks again for asking.

Thank you for taking time to explain. I appreciate it.

Don’t we also accept the confirmation of Eastern Orthodox churches, even though usually done by a priest? Also, in recent years (not sure when it started, maybe post Vatican II?) some confirmations in the Roman Catholic Church are done by priests.

That’s right. This is a great reason why it’s helpful to see how confirmation developed. In the early church (and in the Eastern Orthodox church today), there was a close link between baptism and confirmation, both of which preceded communion. Often, in fact, they occurred during the same service, usually Easter. After months of catechesis, you were baptized, confirmed by the bishop, then welcomed to receive the Eucharist for the first time.

As infant baptism became the norm, and the number of baptisms increased (so the bishop couldn’t get to all of them), confirmation and baptism became separated, but there was still this intuition that the order of baptism-confirmation-communion should still be honored.

This was the case for many Reformed and Anglican churches (the Puritans especially!)–they wanted to maintain infant baptism but also have a stronger accountability for receiving communion worthily.

Not all Prayer Books or Anglicans maintain this line of thought, but if you do use the 1928BCP then there should be a lot more motivation to get confirmed!

It still seems confusing to me why baptism isn’t required by an Anglican priest but confirmation is tied to the bishop. Shouldn’t baptism, tied to being in the Name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit, in other words God doing the baptism, be the same as confirmation, in which the person affirms his faith publicly? That is the heart’s response to what God has done in Baptism……it seems like Anglicanism is always straddling two streams and never settling on one or the other. Either it’s the priestly authority, or it’s the faith of the person and God’s work within….so confusing to me.

This is great! Thank you!

It is wonderful to read this article on Baptism and Confirmation. It brought back memories of attending Confirmation classes in my early teens leading to the actual ceremony and taking communion.
As an older adult now and the many different denominations I have been involved in eg Lutheran (baptised as an infant), Anglican, Churches of Christ, Charismatic, Pentecostal, Baptist I have come to a conclusion that what really matters is sharing the love of Christ with members of my community and wherever I can encourage people to have a relationship with God our Father.
If you read the hearts of each Denomination I believe we all desire the same things.
I thank God for my mother and grandmother who sent my brother and I to Sunday School. God’s seed was planted there.